I've argued before that average graduate salaries would be interesting to use in program and institutional assessment. I've thought that the government ought to report out these average salaries for graduates of an institution to use as an outcomes measure. They have all that data anyway--why not use it for something? I've even made this pitch to people who work in the Department of Education, but I invariably get a stony response.
There's a report shown in the Wall Street Journal showing data collected by a private company to accomplish the same thing. Take a look and see if this isn't useful information. I wish that for comparison's sake, they'd included people who never finished college, or never finished high school.
Disambiguating cause and effect is difficult, of course. Impossible with the data shown. We don't know if MIT graduates earn more than SIU graduates because the school taught them better or the students were better to begin with, or if perhaps they settled in locations nearer their schools, which have different economies. It may say more about what kinds of people attend what kinds of institutions and major in what kinds of subjects than it does about the effectiveness of a program of study in the eventual production of wealth. Still, this kind of information is useful for parents and students considering their options. The fact that median salaries for philosophy majors is slightly more than that of marketing majors makes me happy.
If the government really were to do such a study, using tax records, financial aid data, and clearinghouse data, some clever person might be able to find a control group in order to untangle causes and effects. A good salary shouldn't be the sole end of education (see this book on that topic), but it's an important factor, and undoubtably useful.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
"How much data do you have?" is an inevitable question for program-level data analysis. For example, assessment reports that attem...
-
The annual NACUBO report on tuition discounts was covered in Inside Higher Ed back in April, including a figure showing historical rates. (...
-
I'm scheduled to give a talk on grade statistics on Monday 10/26, reviewing the work in the lead article of JAIE's edition on grades...
-
(A parable for academic workers and those who direct their activities) by David W. Kammler, Professor Mathematics Department Southern Illino...
-
I read Peter Sacks' Standardized Minds a few years ago when I was helping put together our general education assessment process . This...
-
In the last article , I showed a numerical example of how to increase the accuracy of a test by splitting it in half and judging the sub-sco...
-
Introduction Within the world of educational assessment, rubrics play a large role in the attempt to turn student learning into numbers. ...
-
tl;dr Searched SACS reports for learning outcomes. Table of links, general observations, proposal to create a consortium to make public th...
-
Introduction A few days ago , I listed problems with using rubric scores as data to understand learning. One of these problems is how to i...
-
This post is the first of a series on student achievement. The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) summarizes graduation rates...
No comments:
Post a Comment